Construction
Bouygues wins right to pursue High Court challenge over £15.4bn DfE schools framework

The High Court has rejected the Department for Education's argument that Bouygues UK brought its challenge to the £15.4bn Construction Framework 25 too late. The contractor missed the last place on Lot 2 by 0.13 points. The ruling does not decide whether the tender was evaluated lawfully.
Bouygues UK can press ahead with its legal challenge over its exclusion from the Department for Education's £15.4 billion schools construction framework, after the High Court ruled that its claim was brought in time.
In a judgment handed down on 19 November 2026 ([2026] EWHC 2998 (TCC)), Mr Justice Coppel rejected the government's argument that Bouygues had missed the 30-day deadline for bringing a procurement challenge under the Procurement Act 2023. "The Claimant's claims are not time-barred," the judge said.
A 0.13-point gap
The dispute concerns Lot 2 of Construction Framework 25 (CF25), which is mainly for building new and refurbished schools and other educational buildings. The framework was advertised in March 2025 to run for six years from 16 January 2026, with an option to extend by two years, and an estimated initial total value of £15.4 billion. The DfE planned to appoint the ten highest-ranked bidders to Lot 2. Construction News reports that the lot covers higher-value projects in southern and eastern England.
According to the judgment, Bouygues was told on 5 December 2025 that it had come 11th with a score of 74.67. The tenth and last successful bidder, McLaren Construction, scored 74.8. The judgment notes that one extra mark for Bouygues on any question, or one fewer for McLaren, would have been enough to change the outcome, other scores being equal. Bouygues alleges scoring errors and unequal treatment compared with McLaren, and has also raised criticisms of the DfE's moderation process and record-keeping.
The deadline argument
The DfE argued that the limitation period ended on Saturday 3 January 2026. Bouygues's solicitors submitted the claim form through the court's electronic filing system at 16:18 on Monday 5 January. The judge found that the limitation period began on 5 December 2025 and expired on 5 January 2026, the issue date on the claim form. He added that, had the claim been late, he would have granted an extension of time.
The framework has already been entered into. The judgment records that no automatic suspension was triggered when Bouygues issued its claim. Construction News and Construction Enquirer both report the judge as indicating that, if Bouygues ultimately succeeds, damages are a more likely remedy than a place on the framework.
The ruling decides only preliminary issues. Whether the DfE's evaluation was unlawful will be decided later.
Why it matters
The case tests how the courts apply the time limits in the Procurement Act 2023, which replaced the previous public procurement rules. For contractors bidding for public frameworks, it shows how small the margins can be, with a single mark separating success from failure on a multi-billion-pound framework. It is also a reminder that the challenge window is short, and that filing a claim does not necessarily stop a framework from being signed. For suppliers and subcontractors who depend on public sector pipelines, framework places shape workloads for years. Disputes like this can affect who delivers that work and when.
